Quick Read
-
Dave Ramsey told a caller his debt problem stems from insufficient income, not a high interest rate, making rate-shopping a waste of time.
-
Raising a monthly payment from $200 to $500 on an $8,000 balance clears debt in 19 months versus 70, saving over $4,500 in interest.
-
Charging $150 in bills back onto a card while paying $200 monthly causes the balance to grow, making even a 0% transfer useless.
-
Are you ahead, or behind on retirement? SmartAsset’s free tool can match you with a financial advisor in minutes to help you answer that today. Each advisor has been carefully vetted, and must act in your best interests. Don’t waste another minute; learn more here.
Jared is 28. He carries credit card debt on a modest monthly income, and he was still swiping his cards to cover bills when he called The Ramsey Show. Dave Ramsey, the radio host behind the Baby Steps debt plan, co-hosted the episode with Rachel Cruze. He gave his diagnosis in two sentences: “So you don’t have an interest rate problem. You’ve got an income problem.”
A lot of money rides on that call. The average credit card APR is 21%, which is record territory. At that rate, a balance you keep adding to can grow even while you make a payment every month. Shopping for a lower rate feels productive. For someone in Jared’s position, it mostly burns time.
Ramsey Is Right, and the Arithmetic Backs Him
The hosts said on the same episode that personal finance is 80% behavior. On earlier shows, Ramsey’s team added that it is “only 20% head knowledge.” The math still matters here. It just points at the payment.
Here’s an example. Take an illustrative $8,000 balance at the average APR. Interest alone runs about $141 a month.
If you pay $200 a month and charge nothing new, payoff takes about 70 months. You’d pay roughly $6,000 in interest along the way.
——
_________________________________
What’s Your Number…?
Here’s a question most people 5y from retirement can’t answer: at your current savings rate, how much do you need, and how long will it actually last? A good advisor can put a date on that in a single meeting. SmartAsset’s free quiz matches you with up to three fiduciary advisors serving your area, so you can get YOUR retirement number now (sponsor)
__________________________________________
——
The fix most people reach for first is a lower rate. Say a consolidation loan cuts the rate to an example 12%. The same $200 payment now pays off the debt in about 51 months. That helps, but you’re still in debt for more than four years.
The second fix is Ramsey’s: raise the payment. Keep the full rate, pick up extra work, and send $500 a month. The balance is gone in about 19 months, and the total interest stays under $1,500.
The plan with the higher rate ends almost three years sooner. That’s why Ramsey told Jared there is no hack for paying off the balance at his current pace.
Whether Your Card Is Still Paying Bills Decides the Outcome
One factor decides whether any payoff plan works: whether new charges keep landing on the card.
Suppose Jared pays $200 a month but puts $150 of bills on the card. His real progress is just $50 a month against roughly $141 in interest.
The balance grows by about $91 in the first month. He pays every month and still falls further behind.
Even a 0% balance transfer doesn’t save that plan. At $50 of net progress, pays off the balance takes 160 months, which is over 13 years.
Ramsey’s show has also pointed out that these transfers often charge 3 to 5% up front. One host told Jared the goal is “not continuing to go deeper in credit card debt even for bills.”
Ramsey’s priority order makes that possible. Food, shelter, utilities and transportation get paid first, and credit cards come after those essentials. Then the cards get cut up, so the $200 actually goes toward the debt.
A Caller’s Retired Parents Show the Same Problem at 76
Renee called the same show about her parents, who are 73 and 76. They bring in about $4,000 a month and own three homes. Two of those homes house relatives who pay no rent, while her parents cover the taxes and insurance. Her mother was scrounging for grocery money and asking about consolidating her credit cards.
Consolidation would be another rate fix for a behavior problem. Ramsey’s answer was to charge the relatives rent. He also reminded Renee that “debt is not inherited,” so she isn’t at risk “unless you have the inability to say no also.”
…
Read More: Dave Ramsey Says Your Money Habits Matter More Than the Math